When it comes to buying a home, there are many factors buyers consider—price, location, condition, and neighborhood amenities. But there's one factor that often goes unspoken, yet has a profound psychological impact on buyers: a death in the home. Whether natural, accidental, or tragic, a property’s history can influence how it is perceived, priced, and ultimately, how quickly it sells.

Does a Death in the Home Affect Property Value?

In real estate, stigmatized properties—homes that may be psychologically tainted due to events such as murder, suicide, or even rumors of hauntings—often sit on the market longer and may sell for less than comparable homes. Studies show that homes with a reported death can sell for 3% to 15% less than market value, depending on the nature of the death and the cultural perceptions of the buyer.

Buyers may worry about the emotional energy left behind, or simply feel uncomfortable knowing someone passed away on the premises. In some cases, it’s a dealbreaker. For others, it’s a point for negotiation.

Legal Disclosure Varies by State

In the United States, disclosure laws differ by state. For example:

• California requires disclosure if the death occurred within the last three years.

• Texas does not require disclosure unless the death was due to the property’s condition.

• New York generally does not require disclosure of deaths unless the buyer specifically asks.

• In Andover, Massachusetts, and throughout the state, sellers are not legally required to proactively disclose if someone died, committed suicide, or was murdered in a home—unless a buyer specifically asks. This is due to Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 93, Section 114, which explicitly states that properties “psychologically impacted” by crime or death are not considered material facts and need not be disclosed

Buyers concerned about the home's history should always ask their agent directly or research state-specific disclosure laws.

Cultural Sensitivities and Superstitions

Culture plays a major role in buyer sentiment. In some Asian cultures, for instance, a home where someone has died—especially by suicide or murder—is considered extremely unlucky. This can greatly affect resale value and buyer interest in those communities.

How Sellers and Agents Can Navigate the Issue

If you’re selling a home where someone has died, honesty and transparency are key—especially if your state requires disclosure. Here are a few tips:

• Disclose when legally necessary: Always comply with your state’s real estate laws.

• Market the property appropriately: Focus on the home’s strengths—renovations, location, school district, etc.

• Consider professional staging or renovation: A refreshed space can help shift the emotional tone of a home.

• Price accordingly: Be open to adjusting the asking price to reflect market perception.

Should Buyers Be Worried?

For most buyers, the presence of a death in the home shouldn’t raise red flags about the structural safety of the property. But if the event is linked to crime or neglect, it’s wise to have a thorough inspection and investigate local records.

A home’s history matters—not just the physical history, but the emotional one. While not always a dealbreaker, a death in the home is a silent factor that shapes buyer decisions in subtle but important ways.

Whether you're buying or selling, understanding how this element impacts perception and price can help you make more informed real estate choices.

Matt Witte strives to be the best realtor in Andover MA.

Any questions about real estate, reach out to Matt Witte Andover

Realtor MA