Navigating the real estate market can be challenging, especially when dealing with unrealistic home sellers. Whether you're a buyer or an agent, coming across a seller who has an inflated sense of their property’s value or refuses to negotiate can stall a deal—or stop it entirely.

Understanding how to manage this situation effectively is crucial. In this blog, we’ll explore practical tips and insights on how to deal with unrealistic home sellers, so you can keep the transaction moving and protect your interests.

Why Some Home Sellers Are Unrealistic

There are several reasons why a seller may have unrealistic expectations, such as:

• Emotional Attachment: They may value their home based on memories and personal investment rather than market trends.

• Outdated Comparisons: Sellers may use old comps or pre-pandemic pricing.

• Overimprovements: They might assume every upgrade translates into equal market value.

• Lack of Market Knowledge: Some sellers simply don’t understand current conditions or buyer demand.

Understanding the root of their mindset can help you approach them with more empathy and strategy.

Tips for Real Estate Agents: Managing the Conversation

1. Set Expectations Early

Begin with a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) to support your suggested listing price. Show hard data from recent, nearby sales to demonstrate what buyers are actually paying.

2. Communicate the Consequences

Explain how overpricing leads to longer days on the market, price reductions, and missed opportunities. Help them understand that the market ultimately determines the value, not sentiment.

3. Use Professional Staging and Photography

Sometimes unrealistic expectations come from overestimating the home's visual appeal. Professional staging and photography can bridge the gap between perception and reality.

4. Leverage Feedback

If a home has been sitting with no offers or lots of showings but no interest, use buyer and agent feedback to back up your recommendations. This gives third-party validation to your points.

5. Know When to Walk Away

If a seller refuses to acknowledge the market reality, you may need to consider whether the listing is worth your time and energy. Protect your reputation and resources.

Tips for Home Buyers: Navigating Stubborn Sellers

1. Work With an Experienced Agent

A skilled real estate agent will know how to negotiate firmly yet respectfully with difficult sellers and can shield you from unnecessary stress.

2. Don’t Get Emotionally Attached

Even if you love the home, understand when to walk away if the seller won’t budge and the price doesn’t match the value. You have more options than you think.

3. Submit a Strong but Fair Offer

Base your offer on facts—recent sales, appraisal values, and market trends. Include a clear deadline to create urgency.

4. Consider a Personal Letter

In competitive markets, adding a letter to the seller can sometimes break down barriers and make you more relatable. This approach doesn’t always work, but it can help when negotiations stall.

Dealing with unrealistic home sellers is a delicate process that requires patience, strategy, and professionalism. Whether you're a buyer or a real estate agent, the key is to stay grounded in market data, maintain respectful communication, and protect your own financial interests.

By managing expectations and presenting facts clearly, you can turn a difficult situation into a closed deal—or confidently move on to a better opportunity.

Matt Witte strives to be the best realtor in Andover MA.

Any questions about real estate, reach out to Matt Witte, Andover

Realtor MA